deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
×

×
The good side of the bad side of Photobucket

Earlier this evening I read this thread [link] in the Rip Reporting Forum. As I was on Photobucket at the time  - my account there is neither public nor under this nick - I idly searched for "Welshwench" and found one of my fractals. (I only found it because the person who had it on display hadn't changed the title the jpeg would have got when she downloaded it from here so it was "Autumn_Leaves_by_WelshWench").

So I followed the PB instructions (here [link] for anyone interested) and reported it, more out of curiousity than anything else ;) Lo and behold, less than 2 1/2 hours after I sent my mail, I got a reply telling me it had been taken down!

This is the reply I got:

Dear WelshWench,

Thank you for your request that Photobucket, Inc. Photobucket removed the
content located at the following
link(s):[link]

which request was based on your stated belief that such content infringes
your copyrights.  As you may be aware, Photobucket does not itself distribute,
store, or make available most of the content or files available through its
service.  Rather, most all such files or content are put forth by individual
users, and Photobucket has limited control over the content its users may
choose to share.  Nevertheless, Photobucket respects copyright laws and
expects its users to do the same.

Please be advised that Photobucket has removed the above-mentioned content
from its website.

Photobucket's response as set forth herein is a good-faith attempt to
courteously comply with your request at face value.  It should not be taken as
an admission or acknowledgement, of any kind, and Photobucket expressly
reserves all rights at law or in equity.

Should you have any questions about this matter, please contact Photobucket's
Designated Copyright Agent:


Alex Welch
Copyright Agent
Photobucket.com, Inc.
PO Box #13003
Denver, CO  80201
abuse@photobucket.com
Fax: (303) 532-1099


Sincerely,

Your Photobucket Support Team


I have to say I'm impressed at the speed with which they took action.

I have no reason to suspect, from looking at the rest of that person's pics that they are in the habit of ripping off people, but what really pisses me off about PB is that people can click a link to "buy prints" with the result that the printing company (if no-one else) is making a profit from the fact that someone thinks your work would look good in a frame or on a mug or a mousemat or sweatshirt or whatever. This, as much as anything else, is where I think everyone uploading original work to the net should be focussing their anger and action. It's why I got so annoyed with multiply.com last year, despite the fact that the guy who had lots of my fractals on his pages did so with full credit to me and intended it as a compliment.

If anyone is going to make any money out of my work, I want a share of the action :lol:
  • Mood: Irritated
  • Listening to: iPod on shuffle
  • Reading: My message centre
  • Watching: The screen
  • Playing: With UF
  • Eating: Nothing
  • Drinking: Water

43

0 51 0

Details

Stats

Submitted on
July 9, 2007
Views
43
Favourites
0
Comments
51
URL
Thumb
Only verified accounts can report policy violations. Please check your email and click on the verification link.
* Required field
Add a Comment:
 
:iconbrightshade782:
~brightshade782 Jul 10, 2007  Hobbyist Photographer
What happened with multiply.com?
Reply
:iconwelshwench:
Nothing terrible! One of the members there had 8 or 10 of my fractals on his pages. They were full size (as here) and although I was properly credited, he wrote some very complimentary things about my work and was in no way trying to claim they were his work or sell them himself I was really annoyed that there was a "buy prints" link, just like PhotoBucket. Like I said, if anyone is going to be making any money from my work ... it'll be me!! ;)
Reply
:iconbrightshade782:
~brightshade782 Jul 11, 2007  Hobbyist Photographer
Well he said it's your work and people know that because he said it and he expects people to buy YOUR prints from him with no profit to you gee well this is weird I made a rather long random sentence.
Reply
:iconwelshwench:
Ah, *he* wouldn't have made any money himself. But the printing companies that work with sites like mutlyply.com and photobucket do. Yhey don't give a damn who owns the copyright to a photo or piece of art :(
Reply
:iconbrightshade782:
~brightshade782 Jul 12, 2007  Hobbyist Photographer
So even if I post my own work on photobucket, I can't make money off of the prints?
Reply
:iconwelshwench:
Nope. The only people making any profit are the printing companies who offer the service.
Reply
:iconbrightshade782:
~brightshade782 Jul 12, 2007  Hobbyist Photographer
That should be illegal.
Reply
:iconlapurr:
Geez, Gill...more rips. Thanks to Anna, I learned that one of mine is there, too. I found my image and reported it and I expect it will be removed as yours was.

This is getting to be ridiculous.

Thanks for the heads-up.
Reply
:iconwelshwench:
Had a response yet? (Although I guess it's likely still the middle of the night where they are) Talking if which: what are YOU doin up at this unearthly hour? ;)
Reply
:iconlapurr:
No response yet. I have faith.

I've been staying up way too late for a while. :yawnstretch:
Reply
Add a Comment: